Thu 30th Oct 2014 | Last updated: Thu 30th Oct 2014 at 14:45pm

Facebook Logo Twitter Logo RSS Logo

Comment & Blogs

St Francis would have abhorred factory farming

And he could have taught Buddhists a thing or two about respect for animals

By on Monday, 4 October 2010

A depiction of St Francis of Assisi at a church in Glen Head, New York (Photo: CNS)

A depiction of St Francis of Assisi at a church in Glen Head, New York (Photo: CNS)

As today is the special feast day of St Francis of Assisi, and thus my name day, I thought I would add a little to my recent blog on the relationship between human beings and animals.

In his post in response to this blog, M Forrestal was quite right to draw my attention to Catholic teaching on the status of animals in relation to God’s created order. I did not wish to disparage the animal kingdom in any way, merely to attack what I see as a false sentimentality about animals, allied to indifference to nascent human life. Forrestal is right to say that Catholics cannot have it both ways: if we want respect to be shown to pre-born human life, we should also recognise that modern animal husbandry has had a wretched record regarding the treatment of animals intended for human consumption.

St Francis of Assisi would have abhorred factory farming or, indeed, all cruelty towards animals. There is an excellent little CTS booklet about him, in the series Great Saints, which says intriguingly: “It seemed that in [Francis’s] own person he had already reunited a creation, damaged by the Fall, in its pristine union with God and with men. Wild creatures came tamely to him…”

Ah yes, the Fall. It is a central tenet of Christian doctrine that because of the Fall the previous harmony between God and his creation was broken: not just between man and God and man and man, but between man and animals and man and the environment. The results of this are all around us. I certainly believe all the lovely “Fioretti” that have gathered around the person of St Francis: his preaching to the birds, his taming of the wolf of Gubbio and so on. If you are in such close communion with Christ as he was, nothing is impossible. (And you don’t have to watch a film like The Horse Whisperer to know that certain people have a particular “gift” in relation to animals.)

Forrestal’s post adds that Buddhists have much to teach us Catholics about respect towards animals. They would have had nothing to teach St Francis. And he could have shown Eastern faiths that their reverence for living creatures – Jains even carry little brushes so as to sweep the pavement before them in order not to crush insects – is simply a reflection of the respect and worship we give to God himself. Deborah Jones, general secretary of Catholic Concern for Animals and fellow of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics, has written widely on this topic; for those who are interested, her most recent publication is The School of Compassion: A Roman Catholic theology of animals, published by Gracewing.

Last thoughts about St Francis: in case the secularist mafia thinks he is simply a concoction of medieval superstitious Catholic nonsense, I would like to point out other aspects of his life, not just his deep affinity with animals and birds. He is not called “the little poor man” for nothing: our “greed, grab it and run” economy of recent decades would have appalled him. And his response to Islam was classic Christian love: he met with the Sultan al-Malik al-Kamil, ruler in those days of Egypt, Syria and Palestine and, as the CTS booklet says, “so on fire and joyous with the love of God [he] declared he had come to proclaim the Gospel of Jesus Christ and to save the Sultan’s soul…”

  • Jan Fredericks

    If we (especially Franciscans) followed St. Francis' lifestyle which he lived according to Biblical, evangelistic principles, we would not be eating meat, eggs and dairy products as we consume them today. In 'Vegetarian Christian Saints' by Dr. Holly Roberts “Once after he ate a few bites of chicken, he felt such remorse for the chicken that he had his companion tie a rope around him and drag him in the streets.” quoted from Butler Lives of the Saints.

    God looks on all of our hearts instead of what we put in our mouths. He cares about WHY we support factory farms with the support of our buying animals and their products from factory farms. The Israelites wanted meat instead of what God gave them to eat, manna. God gave them quail, but they died and were buried in the Graves of Greed (see Nu. 11:31-35).

    Why do we insist on celebrating Thanksgiving, Christmas and even Easter with the products of animals who suffered their whole lives? God will hold us accountable someday as Hebrews 4:13 states.

    “Blessed are the merciful, for they will obtain mercy.” Jesus

    God's Creatures Ministry

    Jan Fredericks

  • Laura Tieger Salibury

    It has been a day since Pope Francis was elected and I, as an animal lover and activist, hope that this means that compassion and mercy will be combating the forces of greed and cruelty that have resulted in the horrors of factory farming, gestation crates and all forms of abuse and neglect of the creatures of this earth that we are put here to guard. In Jewish tradition, a person is not even allowed to eat hiim/herself before feeding his animals. And the laws of kashrut do not allow any kind of suffering- indeed if the animal suffered then it is not considered kosher anymore. So that would make any kind of slaughterhouse facility where animals are terrorized before being put to death non–kosher.

    I believe that no religion would permit us to treat animals unkindly and if we could only follow St. Francis’ example our world could be restored to “before the fall”.
    As Ghandi said ” You can tell a society by how it treats its animals.
    “I belong to lots of different animal rights groups, the HSUS, ASPCA, Mercy for Animals, Farm Sanctuary, PETA and others for wolf and wildlife protection. I pray that one day my path in life will let me help animals full-time and help end suffering for so many of our companions but until then I thank God for sending us a new leader to help raise consciousness about what it means to love our neighbors ( and I include our animal neighors) as ourslves.