Fri 24th Oct 2014 | Last updated: Fri 24th Oct 2014 at 18:39pm

Facebook Logo Twitter Logo RSS Logo
Hot Topics

Comment & Blogs

Will the new Missal buck the trend and be a nice book?

In the past books were objects of beauty and made to last, that art has been lost

By on Thursday, 14 April 2011

A copy of the Borgianus Latinus, a missal for Christmas made for Pope Alexander VI  (CNS photo/Paul Haring)

A copy of the Borgianus Latinus, a missal for Christmas made for Pope Alexander VI (CNS photo/Paul Haring)

One really does wonder about all the fanfare that is accompanying the new translation of the Roman Missal. The new translation even has its own websiteto which you will be directed from the address Yet it is only a new translation, not a “new Missal”, and not a most certainly not a “new rite”. I have the feeling that once the new translation has been in use for a few weeks people will wonder that they ever used any other.

What really concerns me is the new edition of the Missal, in the sense of the new book which will replace the current edition of the Missal that we all use. Most parishes are using the Roman Missal published by Collins in 1972, which is a lamentable piece of work. Forty years on, most of these books are falling apart, unattractively bound up with sellotape, with pages falling out or going brown with age, and ragged at the edges. The standards of productions were clearly not high. The American editions, not by Collins, were smaller in size, easier to read, and, by and large, have worn very well.

I hope, as a bibliophile, that the new edition of the Roman Missal will be a triumph. In the past books were objects of beauty, and they were made to last. I have read many a novel in a nineteenth century edition which looked almost as good as new; and I have come across plenty of nineteenth and early twentieth century altar Missals that were gorgeously covered, stunningly illustrated, and in excellent condition. Why can’t we make nice books any more? Perhaps the Catholic Truth Society, who are publishing the new edition of the Roman Missal, will buck the trend. The photograph accompanying their sales pitch on the website is encouraging.

As for the old Collins Missals, what are we to do with them?

I have not noticed any official guidance about how these holy books are to be disposed of. Ones in good condition can of course be given to libraries – old liturgical books are a priceless resource, and how we all wish even a few had survived from the early centuries. Ones in poor condition can hardly be left out with the rubbish, so the best thing for them is to be disposed of reverently.

The Jews used to entomb copies of the scriptures that had grown tatty with age, and my suggestion is that old editions of the Missal that are of no further use, whether “hand” missals or altar missals, be placed with the deceased in their coffins, and thus be buried or cremated.

  • R Brown (CTS)

    The new Missal certainly will be beautiful and durable – see this video which demonstrates its features:

  • Anthony Jordan

    I think that it is very important that the present generation avoid the mistakes of the immediate post-Vatican II generation and dispose of these books – although no longer needed – with due reverence. The way in which some liturgical books, vestments and other accoutrements of the old rite were disposed of after the promulgation of the new appears little short of scandalous in some cases and it behoves us to ensure that the transition this time is done with dignity.

  • AgingPapist

    Speaking of “cremation”, an excellent idea for the missal being foisted upon us this Advent. Better just fire ICEL and return to the Douai/Rheims version. Something the bishops should have done more than 40 years ago.