Prominent figures give their views on the Pope's four-day visit

Fr Christopher Jamison, former Abbot of Worth:

There were two high points – from the perspective of the state visit the event in Westminster Hall was memorable for the depth of the Holy Father’s insight and for the warmth of the reception from the British parliamentarians present.

This was a great compliment to Britain in its ability to welcome a religious voice on to the public stage. The Prime Minister’s words at the airport confirmed how his words had struck a chord.

Advert

Secondly from the pastoral point of view the beatification of Cardinal Newman has brought to the attention of many people a great Englishman whose memory will now be celebrated in new ways.

Finally the sheer volume of people on the streets both in Edinburgh and London meant that more than half a million people saw the Pope in person and this demonstration of public support has deeply touched the Holy Father and the entire delegation from the Holy See.

Chris Patten:

I hope the visit will make us think deeper about the sort of society we live in and want to live in. I hope it will make us think more about our social responsibilities. I hope it will make us realise we need a serious dialogue between religious and secular groups.

I hope it will give people of all faiths more self-confidence to stand up for themselves and to make the point that faith matters to society.

Archbishop Patrick Kelly of Liverpool:

“A television interviewer said to me on Sunday ‘You look absolutely radiant’. And that’s been my reaction to four incredible days, which really couldn’t have gone better.”

“We went through such negative publicity before the start of the visit – although not from our local media – but all this negativity has been proved completely wrong.”

“All the cynicism and the negativity has been swept aside by ordinary people – mass gatherings which represented a cross-section of our society, rather than just one group.”

Bishop Crispian Hollis of Portsmouth:

We were all tired at the end of the four days but our weariness can have been nothing compared with that of the Holy Father, who showed remarkable stamina and spirit – and gentle love – throughout the visit.

He has given us all – the Catholic community as well as the nation – much food for thought and much encouragement. He has confirmed us in our faith and we could not have asked for more.

These have been extraordinary blessed days for us all, so let us give heartfelt thanks to the Lord.

Dominic Lawson, columnist and former Sunday Telegraph editor:

Satire apart, I suspect the Pope’s gentle manner and even his very evident physical frailty really did play a part in a reversal of rhetoric by what one might describe as the anti-clerical press. When someone is conjured up as a monster (or “a leering old villain in a frock”, as Richard Dawkins put it) and emerges as a modest scholarly figure visibly ill at ease with the political bombast of a state visit, the opinion-formers sense that their readers will want a more gentle tone.

Guardian:

The Pontiff’s taking of tea with a Queen whose coronation oaths swore her to defend “the Protestant reformed religion established by law” is quite something.

Telegraph:

The Pope’s visit to Britain has demonstrated the abiding strength of Christianity within this nation.

Our hope is that it will act as a reminder that there is a space and a voice for religion in public life – and prompts those of all faiths to find the courage to push back the secularists, and proclaim their beliefs with pride.

Joanna Bogle, author and blogger:

It has been a triumph! In London, history was made as the Pope spoke in Westminster Hall, addressing a gathering that included Members of Parliament, leading figures in public life, and representatives of the nation’s charities, church organisations, and community groups. As he arrived, trumpets were sounded; the trumpeters standing in the niches of the great stained-glass window through which radiant light pours into the great medieval hall. The arches of the great hammerbeam roof have echoed to the great events of British history, notably the trial of St Thomas More, the most significant event of the reign of King Henry VIII.

As long as I live, I will never forget these days. To be in Westminster Hall, where history is written into every inch of the stone-flagged floor and rounded Norman arches, listening to the successor of St Peter speak, was thrilling. To follow this with joyful prayer with young Catholics in the heart of London was glorious, and to stand singing John Henry Newman’s wonderful hymns on an English hillside at a papal Mass was beyond glorious.

Raymond Arroyo, EWTN presenter:

Benedict’s visit was a stand against relativism in the heart of Europe and a plea for Britain to return to herself – to return to her Catholic roots. In a visit worthy of his predecessor, Pope Benedict, with precise language and symbols, communicated a message that will long be felt in England. It was a message controversial and reasonable, bold, and utterly faithful – a simple call, really: England, come home to what you were, and truly are.

Max Clifford, publicist:

Overall, it was a very good thing that he made such a public apology over the child sexual abuse activities. That is something that has been doing huge damage to the Roman Catholic Church.

I think he got better coverage in the British media than I expected. In the build-up to the visit there was far more criticism than praise and then after he arrived far more praise than criticism. The pluses far outweighed the minuses.

From a PR perspective there is a huge amount that needs to be done, but the visit was a success – far more a success than I thought it might have been.

Fr Patrick Daly, priest at St Peter and St Paul church, Wolverhampton

I was at the Mass in Cofton Park yesterday and I found it very uplifting and I have spoken to some of my parishioners who went and they too enjoyed it greatly and thought it was well worth getting up early to go to. The feedback was very positive.

I thought the BBC’s generous and fair-minded coverage helped people come close to a very warm and affectionate Pope Benedict XVI. The English are rather reserved by nature so that reserve (which he has) will have appealed to them.

We are living in a very different world to that of the papal visit of 28 years ago. A lot has changed but the size of the crowds and the warmth of the welcome was I think better than had been expected.

Rather than tackle child abuse he raised it and apologised.

Other issues he raised were the place of religion in public discourse in this country. It was a fair point but I would have thought religion is given a fair innings from the British media.

Brendan O’Neill, editor of Spiked:

Shrill, decadent, profoundly illiberal in sentiment, this protest confirmed what the pope has become for at-sea secularists: an Emmanuel Goldstein figure, who allows them to get their moralistic rocks off.

I’ve said it before and no doubt I’ll have to say it again in the future: I don’t agree with anything that the pope says. But I come from the kind of humanist tradition where, even when that is the case, you will still defend to the death his right to say it.

Terry Sanderson, president of the National Secular Society:

The one positive thing that this visit has brought to us is a stirring of the secular conscience.

The indifference that usually greets religion in this country (and polls before he arrived showed that the lack of interest extended to the Pope) turned into unease at the portrayal of those who want to live without religion as “aggressive” and in some way antipathetic to the good of the country.

Subsequently, 20,000 people turned out in the streets to show the Pope that they will not be dismissed as enemies of society simply because they do not agree with him.

I think the Pope may have unleashed a movement for a legal secularisation in this country that he will come to regret.

Advert

Screen shot 2014-12-17 at 15.36.00