Bishops appeal for change in report prepared for the first family synod
Most German bishops now believe that divorced and remarried Catholics should be allowed to receive Holy Communion, according to a new report published by the German bishops’ conference.
In late December, the bishops published “Theologically Responsible and Pastorally Appropriate Ways for Accompanying the Divorced and Remarried” on the bishops’ conference website.
Matthias Kopp, spokesman for the Bonn-based bishops’ conference, said: “This document contains reflections only and has no juridical power.”
He said the German bishops’ conference hopes “to offer its own theological contribution in this area. While we can give no information about any follow-up, the majority of bishops agreed with the timing of its publication.”
Mr Kopp said the bishops had decided to delay issuing the report, prepared for the extraordinary synod of bishops on the family last October, until the end of 2014. He said the bishops now would concentrate on preparing a formal submission to the worldwide synod assembly in October 2015.
The report, drafted by a working group and approved by the German bishops’ permanent council in June, appeared on December 22 alongside official translations of recent synod documents and German responses to an October 2013 Vatican questionnaire to dioceses worldwide.
It said most of Germany’s 66 bishops now favoured allowing divorced Catholics living in new civil unions to go to Confession and receive Communion in “particular justified instances”.
While a minority of bishops still believed such Catholics “on principle, could not be admitted to the sacraments”, the document added, all now agreed on the need to “intensify pastoral care” for them.
The report said the exclusion of divorced Catholics was “no longer comprehensible” to many priests, some of whom deliberately disregarded Church rules in their pastoral work.
“For many Catholics engaged in Church life, the pastoral care of faithful with a civil divorce and living in new unions is a test of the Church’s credibility,” the document continued.
“The Church’s teaching and pastoral work must uphold Jesus’s instruction on the indissolubility of marriage, but also his invoking of God’s mercy on those who are sinful.”
In a statement on the bishops’ website, Cardinal Reinhard Marx, the German bishops’ conference president, said the report had been approved by a “large majority” of German Church leaders.
He added that the search for pastoral approaches to the divorced and remarried was “one of urgent challenges” facing the Church in its evangelisation worldwide.
“Civil divorce and remarriage often cause people to distance themselves from the Church, or widen the distance they already felt before divorce,” Cardinal Marx said. “It is not uncommon for this evolution to lead to the abandonment of the Christian faith, and this is why the German bishops’ conference wants to step up its pastoral outreach.”
German Church spokesmen have previously defended bishops’ conference proposals to allow some divorced and remarried Catholics to receive sacraments, citing clauses in Pope Francis’ apostolic exhortation Evangelii Gaudium.
In 2013, the Freiburg archdiocese issued a 20-page document setting out guidelines for making Communion available, although these were rejected in in an October 2013 letter by then Archbishop Gerhard Müller, prefect of the Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
German newspapers said several bishops had distanced themselves from the latest conference report, with Bishop Stefan Oster of Passau telling the Passauer Neue Presse daily that he saw “currently no theological possibility” of enabling remarried Catholics to receive Communion without “simultaneously undermining the teaching on marriage’s indissolubility”.
In his website statement, Cardinal Marx said most now concurred that the question of re-admitting them to sacraments “could not be excluded” from pastoral discussions “if Jesus’ message of love is to be heard”.
“For the German bishops, it would not be just to admit all believers whose marriage has broken down and who’ve remarried without distinction,” the bishops’ conference president added.
“By reason of their pastoral experience and on the basis of their theological reflection, they are pleading above all for differentiated solutions, which will respond equitably to each case and permit readmission under certain conditions.”
The accompanying summary of Vatican questionnaire responses said most Germans viewed Catholic views of family life as “too idealistic and unrealistic”, while Church teaching on premarital sex, homosexuality, divorce and contraception were “virtually never accepted”.
It added that a third of marriages ended in divorce in Germany, with around half involving minor-age children, and said Catholic marriages were only slightly “more stable than average”.
The summary said most divorced Catholics considered their separation and new relationship “morally justified” and viewed their consequent exclusion from sacraments as “constituting unjustified discrimination and being merciless”.
Many also saw the Church’s current canonical annulment procedures as “dishonest”, the document added.